When people ask, “Where can I find the best Key Lime Pie in Florida Keys?”, the answer is delicious and fun. The Keys are small islands stretching from Key Largo to Key West. Each island has shops, bakeries, and restaurants that serve amazing slices. So, the best Key Lime Pie in Florida Keys can be just one taste away.
Why is Key Lime Pie So Famous in Florida Keys?
The Key Lime Pie is not just any dessert. It is the official state pie of Florida. Made with tiny Key limes that grow in the region, the pie has a unique sweet and tangy flavor. Unlike the bigger Persian limes found in most grocery stores, Key limes are smaller, yellowish, and have a stronger taste.
The history of this pie goes back to the 1800s. Sailors and locals created it using simple ingredients they had: sweetened condensed milk, egg yolks, and lime juice. Fresh milk and refrigeration were not common at that time, so condensed milk was the perfect choice. Over time, it became a symbol of the Florida Keys.
Where to Find the Best Key Lime Pie in Florida Keys?
As you drive from Key Largo to Key West, you will pass many small shops that sell Key Lime Pie. But where do people say the best one is? The answer depends on who you ask. Here are some popular spots that many visitors love:
- Key Largo: The journey begins with pie shops right at the start of the Keys. Many bakeries here serve fresh slices that pair perfectly with ocean views.
- Islamorada: Known for seafood restaurants and beach bars, this island also offers some of the richest pies with thick graham cracker crusts.
- Marathon: In the middle of the Keys, you’ll find family-run cafes that serve homemade Key Lime Pie recipes passed down for generations.
- Key West: The southernmost island is considered the heart of Key Lime Pie. From old historic bakeries to modern dessert bars, Key West is where you will taste some of the most creative versions of the pie. Some places dip slices in chocolate, while others serve frozen Key Lime Pie on a stick.
So, what is the real best Key Lime Pie in Florida Keys? The truth is, the best pie is the one that matches your taste. Some people like it tart and citrusy, while others prefer it sweet and creamy. The fun is in trying different places and deciding for yourself.
Best Places to Taste Key Lime Pie in the Florida Keys
Food lovers have tasted many pies along the Keys. Here are the top picks people keep talking about:
Top-Ranked Pie Shops (The Cream of the Crop)
- Blond Giraffe Key Lime Pie Factory (Tavernier, Upper Keys): This is often rated #1. Their pie is creamy, tart, and light. You can get it with meringue, whipped cream, or even frozen and dipped in chocolate. A quiet garden is perfect for enjoying your slice.
- Pepe’s Café (Key West): A classic Key West spot. The pie has a thicker, cheesecake-like filling, balanced lime flavor, and a crumbly crust.
- Kermit’s Key West Key Lime Shoppe: A local institution. Famous for double-strength lime juice and chocolate-dipped pie bars on a stick—fun and fresh.
- Midway Café (Islamorada): Known for its great tasting filling. Crust is simple, but the flavor shines through.
- Mangrove Mama’s (Summerland Key): Creamy custard filling and sweet-tart lime flavor, but uses a store-bought crust. Still, it wins many hearts.
- Keys Fisheries (Marathon): Simple, solid, and tasty. Nice texture, balanced flavor—not too fancy, just reliable.
Other Notables
- S.S. Wreck & Galley Grill (Marathon): Some visitors say this may have the best pie in the Keys. Cheesecake-like slice, thick crust, creamy and tart—memorable enough to get served at weddings.
- Burdine’s Waterfront (Marathon): Try their fried Key Lime Pie—a novelty treat with a cinnamon-sugar crust that tastes like a dessert chimichanga.
How to Make the Best Key Lime Pie at Home
Cuisine: American / Florida Keys specialty
Course: Dessert
Cook Time: 15 minutes plus 2–3 hours chilling
Total Time: Around 3 h 20 m
Servings: 8 slices
Ingredients:
- 1½ cups graham cracker crumbs
- 6 tbsp melted butter
- 3 tbsp sugar
- 3 egg yolks
- 14 oz can sweetened condensed milk
- ½ cup Key lime juice (fresh or bottled)
- Whipped cream or meringue for topping
Instructions:
Preheat oven to 350 °F. Mix crumbs, butter, and sugar to make the crust. Press into a pie dish and bake 10 minutes until light golden. Beat yolks, add condensed milk and mix. Stir in lime juice until smooth. Pour filling into crust and bake 15 minutes until set. Let cool and chill in fridge 2–3 hours. Top with whipped cream or meringue. Slice and enjoy!
Variations of Key Lime Pie
The Florida Keys are famous for experimenting with different versions of this dessert. Here are a few creative variations:
- Frozen Key Lime Pie: Served cold and frozen, sometimes even dipped in chocolate.
- No-Bake Key Lime Pie: Made with gelatin or cream cheese, perfect for hot summer days.
- Mini Key Lime Pies: Small bite-sized pies for parties and gatherings.
- Chocolate Key Lime Pie: Rich and tangy with a chocolate crust or drizzle.
Nutrition Facts for Key Lime Pie
- Calories: 350
- Carbohydrates: 45g
- Fat: 16g
- Protein: 5g
- Sugar: 35g
When you ask locals and visitors about the best Key Lime Pie in Florida Keys, you’ll hear many different answers. Some swear by old family recipes in Marathon, while others say Key West holds the crown. The truth is, each slice you try brings you closer to the real spirit of the Keys.
Whether you enjoy it in a cozy cafe overlooking the ocean, in a lively Key West dessert bar, or at home with your own recipe, the Key Lime Pie will always remind you of the sunshine, the sea breeze, and the charm of Florida Keys.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
1. What makes Key Lime Pie different from regular lime pie?
Key limes are smaller, tangier, and more aromatic than regular limes. This gives the pie its special taste that you can’t get from larger limes.
2. Is Key Lime Pie better with whipped cream or meringue?
This is a personal choice. Whipped cream makes the pie lighter and creamier, while meringue adds a sweet, fluffy topping. Both are delicious.
3. Can I use bottled Key lime juice?
Yes, bottled Key lime juice is widely available and works well when fresh limes are not in season. Many famous Florida Keys restaurants also use bottled juice.
4. How long does Key Lime Pie last in the fridge?
The pie can last up to 3-4 days in the refrigerator. Just make sure it is covered to stay fresh.
5. Where can I find the absolute best Key Lime Pie in Florida Keys?
Key West is often considered the top place to try, but the best pie is the one that matches your taste buds. Many travelers recommend trying slices in different islands along the way and picking your own favorite.
